To Investigate the Quality of Olive Oils Distributed in the Market Based on the Determined Specifications in the National Standard of Iran

Document Type : Research Paper

Authors

1 department of food science, faculty of food industries and agriculture, Standard research institute, Karaj, Alborz, Iran

2 Research standard Institute of Iran

Abstract

Introduction: Today olive oil is widely produced and consumed in different countries due to its good taste and valuable nutritional properties (Moldao-Martins et al. 2004). Olive oil fatty acid profiles consist of saturated fatty acids (about 11%), monounsaturated fatty acids (in particular oleic acid) (about 80%), and polyunsaturated fatty acids (approximately 9%). In addition, olive oil contains antioxidant and anti-inflammatory compounds such as squalene, phytosterol, tocopherols, polyphenols, aromatic compounds and coloring pigments (Rafehi et al. 2012; Hernaez et al. 2015). These compounds have important effects on human health, nutritional value, sensory properties and oil stability (Kalua et al. 2007). Based on definition provided by Iranian national standard (1446) olive oil is obtained solely from the fruit of the olive tree to the exclusion of oils obtained using solvents or re-esterification processes and of any mixture with other kind of oil. It is marketed in accordance with the following designations and definitions: virgin olive oils, refined olive oil, olive-pomace oil and olive oil. Virgin olive oils are more expensive than other kind of olive oils because of their good taste and good nutritional values; therefore sometimes virgin olive oil sold is adulterated, cut with poor quality olive oil or cheaper oils such as sunflower and soybean oil (Moreda et al. 2003). Recently, there is a suspicion among consumers and regulatory agencies that some manufacturers (to increase their profits) have labeled lower quality olive oils as a virgin or extra virgin olive oil. A comprehensive study of food fraud over a 30-year period showed that the highest amount of food fraud was related to the olive oil. The study used scientific papers published between 1980 and 2010 (Moore et al. 2012). Therefore the aim of the current study was to investigate the properties of different types of olive oils (including virgin, refined and olive oil), distributed in the Iranian market.
Material and methods: Total of 18 samples of olive oil including, virgin olive oil (5 samples), ordinary virgin (3 samples), refined olive oil (5 samples) and olive oil (5 samples) were collected from the market (Table 1). The samples were transferred to the laboratory and kept in the refrigerator (4 °C) until they were analyzed. physicochemical and qualitative experiments (including acidity, peroxide, moisture content, insoluble impurities, extinction coefficient (K270, K232, k)); and oil purity (including identification and determination of sis and trans fatty acid, sterols, erythrodiol and uvaol content, 2-glyceryl monopalmitate, unsaponifiable matter, and ECN 42) were determined. Each sample was tested three times and the results were reported as "mean±standard deviation". Physicochemical properties including acidity, peroxide, moisture and insoluble impurities were measured according to the national standards No 4178, 4179, 4291, and 4095 respectively. The extinction coefficient (K232, K270, K) was determined using a spectrophotometer (EU 2200, ONLAB). Fatty acid profile was determined according to standard No 13126 (2016). Oil samples were sterified in methanol solution (2 M) for 30 min at 50 °C and methyl ester of fatty acids were determined by gas chromatography (GC-Yung Lin 6500) equipped with flame ionization detector (FID). Nitrogen gas (at the flow rate of 4 ml/min) was used as the carrier gas. The ECN 42 was calculated based on Iranian National Standard No17379. The 2-monoglycerol palmitate was measured using a gas chromatography equipped with a flame ionization detector (FID). The chromatographic column used was DB-5 (15m*0.25mm*0.53µm). Sterol and triterpene dialcohol composition including, desmethylsterol composition (% total sterols), Total sterol content, and Erythrodiol and uvaol content were determined using GC based on method provided by Iranian national standard (ISIRI 16324). All obtained results for olive oils were subjected to statistical analysis using statistical software (Minitab, 17:0, PA., State College, USA). The significant differences between mean values were determined by analysis of variance (ANOVA) with Post Hoc Tukey’s test. A probability value of 0.05 was used to determine the statistical significance. All data are reported as means ± standard deviations.
Results and discussion: Results showed that 8 out of 18 samples (44%), did not comply with standard 1446 (at least in one of the specifications). In 4 samples (about 22%) acidity was higher than the maximum permitted level in national standard No 1446 (Table 2). Acidity is one of the important criteria in the classification of olive oil types. This characteristic indicates the quality of the fruit used for oil production and its production conditions. One reason for the increase in acidity is the activation of enzymes by damage to olive fruit (Zegane et al. 2015). All samples were in compliance with the national standard 1446 in terms of peroxide values, moisture content, volatiles compound, and extinction coefficients (Table 2). The results of insoluble impurities in light petroleum showed that in two samples of olive oil and one sample of refined oil this value was higher than the maximum permitted level set by Iranian national standard (Table 2). Unsaponifiable matter in all samples varied between 0.71 and 1.82 g/kg and was in agreeing with related standard (Table 5). The fatty acid profiles of the investigated olive oil samples (C16 to C20) are shown in Table 3. In all samples, oleic and palmitic acids were the most abundant fatty acids followed by linoleic and stearic acid, respectively. The highest mean oleic acid (72.04±2.2) was related to refined olive oil. The results of this study were in agreement with those of other researchers (Matthaus et al., 2011). The trans fatty acids were not detected in any of the samples. The results obtained for sterol and triterpene dialcohol composition including, desmethylsterol composition (% total sterols), Total sterol content (mg/kg), erythrodiol and uvaol content (% total sterols) are presented in Tables 4 and 5. Desmethylsterol is composed of cholesterol, brassicasterol, campesterol, stigmasterol, delta-7-stigmastenol, and apparent beta-sitosterol. In two oil samples (43 and 14), the amount of Brassica sterol was higher than the standard limit (maximum 0.1%), showing that the other vegetable oils may have been added to olive oil. Maximum difference between the actual and theoretical ECN 42 triacylglycerol content are presented inTable 5. Results showed in 3 out of 18 samples (about 17%) ΔECN 42 was higher than standard limit.In all 18 samples, the amount of 2-monoglycerol palmitate ranged from 0.1% to 0.8% and was in accordance with national standard 1446 (Table 5).
Conclusion: Examination of 18 olive oil samples showed that olive oils distributed in the market, has an acceptable level of quality. The highest amount of non-conformity was related to the amount of sterols followed by acidity. Trans fatty acids were not detected in any of the samples.However, the characteristics studied in this study were not able to detect the virgin olive oil from those with lower quality (refined and olive oil). Therefore other experiments such as wax content and aliphatic alcohols are necessary to determine the small amount of olive pomace oil and stigmastadiene is needed to determine whether the olive oil is mixed with other vegetable oils. This study showed that it is difficult to distinguish between different types of olive oils and further research is necessary.

Keywords


پاشایی آ و شواخی ف،1396 ، استفاده از روش گرماسنجی برای تعیین تقلب روغن زیتون فوق بکر با روغن کلزا به عنوان
جایگزین روش کروماتوگرافی گازی، نشریه پژوهشهای صنایع غذایی،27(3)، 149-139
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1376 .اندازه گیری مواد غیر قابل صابونی توسط استخراج با هگزان – روش سریع، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 4097.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1395. روغن زیتون -طیف سنجی نوری در ناحیه فرابنفش (اندازه گیری ضریب خاموشی ) روش آزمون، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 10503.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1395. روغن‌ها و چربی های گیاهی و حیوانی -کروماتوگرافی گازی متیل استرهای اسید چرب -قسمت 1- اندازه گیری با کروماتوگرافی گازی مدرن متیل استرهای اسید چرب –راهنما، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 1-13126.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1392. روغن زیتون -تعیین اختلاف میزان تئوری و واقعی تری آسیل گلیسرول ها با استفاده از روش ECN42، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 17379.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1391. روغن‌های زیتون و روغن‌های تفاله زیتون -تعیین مقدار 2-گلیسریل منوپالمیتات، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 14657.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1391. روغن زیتون -تعیین مقدار استرول ها و تری ترپن دی الکل‌ها به روش کروماتوگرافی گازی با استفاده از ستون موئین -روش آزمون، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 16324.
سازمان ملی استاندارد، 1390. روغن زیتون-ویژگیها و روش‌های آزمون، استاندارد ملی ایران شماره 1446.
Ahangar Banadkooki S, Piravi Vanak Z, Hadad Khodaparast MH, Safafar H, 2013. Effect of the temperature on ΔECN 42 of Iranian olive oil. Journal of Food Science and Technology 39(10): 43-48.
Aued-Pimentel S, Takemoto E, Kumagai EE, Cano CB, 2008.Calculation of the difference between the actual and theoretical ecn 42 triacylglyceride content to detect adulteration in olive oil samples commercialized in brazil. Quim. Nova 31(1): 31-34.
Ben Temime S, Manai H, Methenni K, Baccouri B, Abaza L, Daoud D, Casas JS, Bueno EO, Zarrouk M, 2008. Sterolic composition of Che´toui virgin olive oil: Influence of geographical origin. Food Chemistry 110: 368–374.
Boudour-Benrachou N, Jérôme P, Pinate C, Artaud J, Dupuy N, 2017. Fatty acid compositions of olive oils from six cultivars from East and South-Western Algeria. Advances in Food Technology and Nutritional Sciences 1: 1-5.  
Boulkroune H, Lazzez A, Guissous M, Bellik Y, Smaoui S, Kamoun N.G and Madani T, 2017. Characterization of sterolic and alcoholic fractions of some Algerian olive oils according to the variety and ripening stage. OCL, 24(5): A502.
Desouky IM, Haggag LF, Abd El-Migeed MMM, El-Hady ES, 2009. Changes in some physical and chemical properties of fruit and oil in some olive oil cultivars during harvesting stage. World Jouranl Agriculture Science 5(6): 760–765.
Cimato A, 1990. Effect of agronomic factors on virgin olive oil quality. Olivae 31: 20-31.
El-Hamdy AH, El-Fizga NK, 1995,Detection of olive oil adulteration by measuring its authenticity factor using reversed-phase high-performance liquid chromatography, Journal of Chromatography A708(2): 351-355.
Hernaez A, Remaley AT, Farràs M, Fernandez-Castillejo S, Subirana I, Schroder H, Fernandez-Mampel M, Muñoz-Aguayo D, Sampson M, Sola R, 2015. Olive oil polyphenols decrease LDL concentrations and LDL atherogenicity in men in a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Nutrition 145(8): 1692–1697.
Kalua CM, Allen MS, Bedgood DR, Bishop AG, Prenzler PD, Robards K, 2007. Oive oil volatile compounds, flavour development and quality: A critical review. Food Chemistry 100 (2007): 273–286.
Lopez-Cortes I, Salazar-García DC, Velazquez-Martí B, Salazar DM, 2013. Chemical characterization of traditional varietal olive oils in East of Spain. Food Research International 54: 1934-1940.
Matthaus B, Ozcan MM, 2011. Determination of fatty acid, tocopherol, sterol contents and 1,2- and 1,3-Diacylglycerols in four different virgin olive oil. Journal of Food Processing and Technology 2(117): 2-4.
Mendoza MF, De Miguel Gordillo C, Expóxito JM, Sanchez J, Manuel C, Canod M, Vertedorc DM, Baltasar DMF, 2013. Chemical composition of virgin olive oils according to the ripening in olives. Food Chemistry 141(3): 2575-2581.
Moldao-Martins M, Beirao-da-Costa S, Neves C, Cavaleiro C, Salgueiro L, Beirao-da-Costa ML, 2004. Olive oil flavoured by the essential oils of Mentha piperita and Thymus mastichina L. Food Quality and Preference 15(5): 447–452.
Moore JC, Spink J, Lipp M, 2012. Development and application of a database of food ingredient fraud and economically motivated adulteration from 1980 to 2010. Journal of Food Science 77(4): 118-126.
Moreda W, Pérez-Camino MC, Cert A, 2003. Improved method for the determination of triacylglycerols in olive oils by high performance liquid chromatography Grasas y Aceites 54(2): 175-179.
Noorali M, Barzegar M, Sahari MA, 2014. Sterol and fatty acid compositions of olive oil as an indicator of cultivar and growing area. Journal of American Oil and Chemical Society 91(9): 571-1581.
Moreno OA, Dorantes L, Galindez J, Guzman RI, 2003. Effect of different extraction methods on fatty acids, volatile compounds, and physical and chemical properties of Avocado (Persea americana Mill.) oil. Journal of Agricultural and Food Chemistry 51(8): 2216–2221.
Rafehi H, Ververis K, Karagiannis TC, 2012. Mechanisms of action of phenolic compounds in olive. Journal of Dietary Supplements 9(2): 96-109.
Salvador MD, Aranda F, Gomez-Alonson S, Fregapane G, 2000. Quality characteristics of Cornicabra virgin olive oil. Research Advance in Oil Chemistry 1: 31-39.
Skevin D, Kraljic K, Miletic L, Obranovic M, Neđeral S, Petricevic S, 2011. Adulteration of Oblica virgin olive oil with edible sunflower and refined olive pomace oil, Croatian Journal of Food Technology, Biotechnology and Nutrition 6 (3-4): 117-122.
Yorulmaz HO, Konuskan DB, 2017. Antioxidant activity, sterol and fatty acid compositions of Turkish olive oils as an indicator of variety and ripening degree. Journal of Food Science and Technology 54(12): 4067-4077.
Zegane O, Keciri S, Louaileche H, 2015. Physicochemical Characteristics and Pigment Content of Algerian Olive Oils: Effect of Olive Cultivar and Geographical Origin. International Journal of Chemical and Biomolecular Science 1(3): 153-157.